Best Tennant special

Which is the best story out of the 2008-9 specials? I’d go for The Waters Of Mars by default, mainly due to how crap the rest are.
Though I’ve always found WOM rather overrated anyway.

Waters of Mars, by default. The Next Doctor I actually think was decent, but it should have only focused on the Doctor and Jackson Lake, and the Cybermen sequences were mediocre. I don't even remember what happened in Planet of the Dead to be honest.

Waters of Mars. But it wasn't especially good.

SomeCallMeEnglishGiraffe wrote:Waters of Mars, by default. The Next Doctor I actually think was decent, but it should have only focused on the Doctor and Jackson Lake, and the Cybermen sequences were mediocre. I don't even remember what happened in Planet of the Dead to be honest.

There was a bus, a desert, Lee Evans and a lady from Eastenders who was briefly the Bionic Woman for 8 or 9 episodes.

It's like choosing between different dog shit colours.

I liked The Next Doctor, but Waters of Mars is an absolute classic. The flood were among the most genuinely terrifying monsters in the series. Just a shame it leads into The End of Time.

They're all total shite, but I went for The Next Doctor because it's the only one that I can remotely remember.

The Next Doctor. Even though the climax is dire.

The Next Doctor simply because of Morrissey.

One of the easier votes. Waters, even if it's slightly overrated and the moral issues at the end are not so much spoon fed to the audience as shovelled to them.