Rob Filth wrote: Both of them have many of the same attractions. I also really like the interaction between all of the characters in original Dare too, the chumminess of it without them all having ulterior urge-driven lust motives.
The world building and attention to detail is fantastic in original Dan Dare too, in many ways it reminds me of TinTin, it's a damn shame the run was not widely distributed as graphic novels decades ago.
Agreed, I am glad that Dan Dare had mostly platonic relationships with his female friends. I'm no prude and sometimes a love story can be interesting, but still its annoying the way it has to seep its way into everything.
I actually think Dan Dare had not bad female characters. Peabody, Doctor Rodan, Princess Myriad, and Morag, all very diverse characters, all had a different relationship with Dan. Its just a shame we never got to see more of the likes of Myriad.
I think the Treens really are the daddy of all of the Doctors main adversaries when you think about it.
They are obviously the precursors to the Daleks. Like the Daleks they are xenophobic Nazi parallels who are ruled by a fuhrer figure who has a dome shaped head and is a crippled megalomaniac.
The Treens and the Daleks are the perfect monsters as they represent the darkest aspects of humanity. Hating people for being different, all following one, pathetic, inadequate man, losing all individuality etc.
Thus whilst both where intended to represent the Nazis you can actually use them as metaphors for other twisted and evil people throughout history too. The Treens for instance can be seen to represent the Apartheid regime in South Africa. The way they live in a segregated area from the brown skinned Therons, whilst keeping other life forms similar to the Therons as their servants. (The fact that its a black guy who leads the final attack that brings down the Treen regime is also a nice irony too.)
At the same time the Daleks can also be seen to represent the likes of General Chivington, the monster who carried out the Sand Creek Massacre, whose attitudes towards the Native Americans mirrored those of the Daleks towards their enemies.
It was also reported that following the massacre, some members of Congress had confronted Chivington and the Governor, before members of the public at the Denver Opera House. At one point it was asked whether it would be better to civilize or exterminate the Indians. In a letter from one of the senators to a friend, he wrote that "there suddenly arose such a shout as is never heard unless upon some battlefield—a shout almost loud enough to raise the roof of the opera house—'EXTERMINATE THEM! EXTERMINATE THEM!'"
I always thought it would be interesting to do a historical story about the Sand Creek Massacre and have the Doctor witness this moment. Audiences would think it was made up, but it would actually be real.
At the same time the Treens are like the Cybermen, (Kit Pedler even said they were among his main inspirations.)
The Treens and the Cybermen both represent technology being abused to the point where you lose your humanity. Though the Treens didn't physically turn themselves into machine creatures, but they removed their humanity and emotions.
Also much like the Cybermen the evil Treens who are loyal to the Mekon are desperate. They like the Cybermen lose their base of operations and are forced to go on the run. When I watched the Moonbase the other day it really felt like a live action Dan Dare story like Marooned on Mercury where the Treens now on the run need to destroy the earth.
Also the Cybermen's leader, the Cyber Controller was intended to be a small, big brained creature like the Mekon, but they didn't have the budget, but they still kept his big head.
Dan Dare meanwhile much like the Doctor is the antithesis to the Daleks/Cybermen/and Treens. The Doctor treats everyone as equals, even though he comes from the most advanced society in the universe. His technology is also used in a positive way to take him to places where people need help, unlike the Cybermen. Similarly Dan is the same he comes from a society that treats everyone equally and his advanced technology is always used to help people.
This coupled with the fact that Dan and the Doctor are both the quintessential British gentlemanly hero who often travel with intelligent female characters (Peabody, Rodan) IMO makes Dan more comparable to the Doctor than any other character.