Divide the Baker stories

Classics:

Revelation of the Daleks
The Two Doctors

Good:

Attack of the Cybermen
Timelash
Terror of the Vervoids

Average:

The Twin Dilemma
The Mark of the Rani
The Ultimate Foe


Bad/Turkeys:

The Mysterious Planet
Mindwarp
Vengeance on Varos

Classics:

Attack
Two Doctors

Very good
Varos
Revelation

Decent
Twin Dilemma
Mark
Vervoids (SE)

Turkeys
Timelash
Trial

Classics
Revelation Of The Daleks
The Two Doctors
Vengeance On Varos

Good
Attack Of The Cybermen
Terror Of The Vervoids
Mark Of The Rani

[u]Mediocre[/u]
Timelash
Twin Dilemma
The Mysterious Planet
The Ultimate Foe

Bad
Mindwarp

Fucking hell...

How is this any different from a straight-up points ranking?

You don't think posters could infer what you do and don't like from those threads?

Fuck this shit.

Boofer wrote:Fucking hell...

How is this any different from a straight-up points ranking?

You don't think posters could infer what you do and don't like from those threads?

Fuck this shit.

Why does it bother you so much? If you don't like the idea of the thread then I suggest you

Classics:
The Mark of the Rani
The Two Doctors
Attack of the Cybermen

Good:
Timelash
The Mysterious Planet
Terror of the Vervoids

Average:
Vengeance on Varos
Revelation of the Daleks
The Ultimate Foe

Bad/Turkeys:
The Twin Dilemma
Mindwarp

Classics:

Revelation of the Daleks
The Two Doctors
Attack of the Cybermen


Good:

Mark of the Rani. Apart from the daft shit about sbdy turning into a tree.
The Ultimate Foe
Terror of the Vervoids.


Average:

Timelash
The Twin Dilemma


Bad/Turkeys:

The Mysterious Planet. Could - should - have been better.
Vengeance on Varos. Because of Sil. Hate it.
Mindwarp.

Classics:

None

Good:

Revelation of the Daleks
Attack of the Cybermen

Average:

Terror of the Vervoids
The Ultimate Foe
Vengeance on Varos
The Two Doctors

Bad/Turkeys:

The rest.

Ludders wrote:Classics:

None

What is your definition of a classic?

Pepsi Maxil wrote:

What is your definition of a classic?

9/10 or above.

Ludders wrote:

Pepsi Maxil wrote:

What is your definition of a classic?

9/10 or above.

I mean, are there specific elements that make a story a "classic" to you?

The word "Hinchcliffe" in the end titles.

iank wrote:The word "Hinchcliffe" in the end titles.

Producer

John Nathan-Turner



is what really gets my penis throbbing

Integral components have to be spot on. It has to be well written and well acted. Poor performances from bit parts are forgivable, but not main characters.
This particular story almost makes it for me, but not quite. It's an 8 or 8.5/10.

iank wrote:The word "Hinchcliffe" in the end titles.

You should check my Hinchcliffe rankings. Lots in there below 9/10.